Why the Minnesota Vikings Shouldn't Give Into Dalvin Cook's Contract Demands

In the last year, both the Dallas Cowboys and the Carolina Panthers extended their franchise running backs to massive contracts.

Before the start of the 2019 season, the Cowboys and Ezekiel Elliott agreed to a six-year, $90 million contract extension. In April, McCaffrey and the Panthers agreed to a four-year contract worth $64 million.

The next domino to fall could be Vikings running back Dalvin Cook. According to ESPN, Cook will not attend any team-related activities until he receives a contract extension. Although Dalvin Cook was one of the best running backs during the 2019 season, he could be waiting a while for that new contract.

Latest NFL News

Minnesota shouldn’t give into Cook’s demands simply because he has shown the inability to remain healthy during his career. During his three seasons in the league, Cook has never played in 16 games in a season.

Last season, Cook missed two games because of a shoulder injury. In 2018, Cook played in 11 games as he missed time due to a nagging hamstring injury. As a rookie in 2017, Cook tore his ACL as he was limited to just four games.

Sure, Cook rushed for 1,135 yards and 13 touchdowns and finished with 1,654 all-purpose yards and accounted for a considerable part of their offense a season ago. But paying a player who has had only one great season and injuries concerns doesn’t seem like the best recipe for success.

Cook is set to make $1.33 million in the final season of his contract, so it is understandable why he wants a new deal. The shelflife of a running back is short compared to other positions on the football field. Plus, Cook knows with his injury history, this could be his only chance to break the bank.

But if you’re the Vikings, this doesn’t financially make a lot of sense, especially with the depth in their backfield.

They may not be on Cook’s level, Ameer Abdullah, Mike Boone, Tony Brooks-James, and Alexander Mattison have the talent to make up for a big part of Cook’s production. Mattison was the Vikings’ second-best running back in 2019 with 462 yards and one touchdown on 100 carries. Abdullah has also been a contributor as a runner during his time with the Detroit Lions.

Reports are Cook is looking for at least $13 million per year, which was what the Arizona Cardinals gave David Johnson when he signed his extension in September 2018. A year later, Johnson was demoted and then traded to the Houston Texans this offseason for DeAndre Hopkins.

Ep 22: QB Futures; Pats/Bills; Week 13 Props and Predictions
by Full Press Coverage on December 5, 2021 at 4:20 pm
Ian, Braden, and Ricky discuss the […]

NFL Leading Rushers – 2019


					Rush	Rush	Rush	Rush	Rush
Rk	Player	Tm	Age	Pos	Att	Yds ▼	TD	Y/A	Y/G	Fmb
1	Derrick Henry*	TEN	25	RB	303	1540	16	5.1	102.7	5
2	Nick Chubb*	CLE	24	RB	298	1494	8	5.0	93.4	3
3	Christian McCaffrey*+	CAR	23	RB	287	1387	15	4.8	86.7	1
4	Ezekiel Elliott*	DAL	24	RB	301	1357	12	4.5	84.8	3
5	Chris Carson	SEA	25	RB	278	1230	7	4.4	82.0	7
6	Lamar Jackson*+	BAL	22	QB	176	1206	7	6.9	80.4	9
7	Leonard Fournette	JAX	24	RB	265	1152	3	4.3	76.8	1
8	Josh Jacobs	OAK	21	RB	242	1150	7	4.8	88.5	1
9	Joe Mixon	CIN	23	RB	278	1137	5	4.1	71.1	0
10	Dalvin Cook*	MIN	24	RB	250	1135	13	4.5	81.1	4

Provided by Pro-Football-Reference.com: View Original Table

In July 2018, the Los Angeles Rams signed Todd to a four-year, $60 million contract extension with $45 million in guarantees. Gurley, much like Cook, has had injury concerns and failed to live up to that contract, which was why the Rams decided to release him this offseason.

Melvin Gordon took the risk of holding out even as the 2019 season began. But he eventually ended his holdout in late September despite not receiving the contract extension he sought. In the process, Austin Ekeler proved himself in Gordon’s absence, and the Chargers eventually rewarded him with a four-year, $24.5 million contract this offseason. This was after the Chargers reportedly offered Gordon as much as $10 million per year, but Gordon declined it at the time.

Cook had an excellent 2019 season, and he certainly could do that again in 2020. But he certainly doesn’t have the track record to warrant a contract in the stratosphere of Elliott and McCaffrey.

It would be in Cook’s best interest to report for training camp and play on the final year of his rookie contract. If Cook were to sit out the entire year, he would be a restricted free agent, and that could cost him millions of dollars. Cook just needs to bet on himself, and he could possibly be rewarded if not by the Vikings, by somewhere else.