Shedeur Sanders Gets His Chance — Even With Deshaun Watson Available

Shedeur Sanders is getting his chance in Cleveland.

And this time, it is not because the Browns have no other option.

Deshaun Watson has cleared concussion protocol and is officially available again, but head coach Todd Monken is still turning the offense over to Sanders for Sunday’s game against the New Orleans Saints.

For a 5-3 team trying to stay in the AFC North race, that makes this much more than a temporary injury replacement.

Shedeur Sanders Will Start Against New Orleans

Cleveland named Sanders the starter earlier in the week while Watson was still working his way through concussion protocol.

That alone would have made sense.

What makes the decision more interesting is what happened next.

Watson was cleared from the protocol Saturday, yet Cleveland did not change course.

Sanders is still starting.

That means the Browns are choosing to see what he can do with a full week of preparation, even though their veteran starter is no longer medically unavailable.

This Is Different From Last Season

Sanders already has starting experience.

As a rookie in 2025, he started seven games while Watson recovered from Achilles surgery. Cleveland went 3-4 in those starts, with Sanders completing 56.6 percent of his passes for 1,400 yards, seven touchdowns and 10 interceptions.

There were flashes.

There were also obvious growing pains.

He lost the preseason competition to Watson this summer and has barely played in 2026, completing all three of his pass attempts for just two yards in limited action.

Sunday gives him something he has not had this season:

A real start.

Why the Browns Are Making the Move

The Browns are not benching Watson because he has been terrible.

That matters.

Watson has completed 65.5 percent of his passes for 1,806 yards, seven touchdowns and three interceptions while helping Cleveland reach 5-3.

But the offense has also become increasingly difficult to sustain.

Watson has taken a league-high 33 sacks, and Cleveland scored only six points in last week’s loss to Pittsburgh despite gaining 319 yards.

At some point, moving the football has to turn into points.

Sanders now gets the chance to see if he can change that.

The Saints Are a Good Test

New Orleans is not the kind of opponent that should overwhelm a young quarterback before the game even starts.

That makes Sunday a useful evaluation.

The Browns do not need Sanders to throw for 350 yards.

They need him to manage the offense, avoid negative plays, keep the pass rush from dictating the game and create enough explosive plays to prevent New Orleans from crowding the line of scrimmage.

If he can do that, the conversation changes quickly.

The Biggest Issue Is Protection

The easiest way for this experiment to fail would be for Cleveland’s protection problems to follow Sanders into the lineup.

Watson’s league-high sack total is not solely on the offensive line. Quarterbacks influence pressure with timing, pocket movement and decision-making.

That makes Sanders’ processing especially important Sunday.

Can he get the ball out quickly?

Can he avoid turning a broken play into a 10-yard loss?

Can he use his mobility without drifting into pressure?

Those answers may matter more than the final passing total.

This Is a Real Opportunity, Not Just a Spot Start

If Watson had remained in the concussion protocol, Sanders starting would be straightforward.

Watson clearing the protocol changes the meaning.

Cleveland had an opportunity to immediately hand the job back to its veteran quarterback.

It chose not to.

That does not mean Sanders has permanently taken the job.

It does mean the Browns are willing to see where this goes.

For a team that is 5-3 and still very much alive in the AFC North, that is a meaningful decision.

What Happens Next?

Sanders starts Sunday in New Orleans.

Watson is healthy enough to play, although Cleveland has not publicly committed to how the backup situation will look on game day.

If Sanders plays well, Monken will face a much more difficult decision next week.

If he struggles, the Browns can go right back to Watson.

But for one Sunday, the offense belongs to Shedeur Sanders.

And unlike last year, this time Cleveland is choosing to give it to him.

Want to write, edit, host, or produce with FPC? Join the staff →