The phrase “final 53” is one of football’s great lies.
There’s nothing final about it.
Miami made seven waiver claims Monday. Other teams immediately began building practice squads, signing veterans and altering rosters that had technically been finalized less than 24 hours earlier.
That’s because cutdown day doesn’t always provide answers.
Sometimes it reveals the questions.
Here are five teams whose initial rosters left me wanting to know considerably more.
1. Miami Dolphins
The question: What exactly is the timeline here?
Miami might have produced the most fascinating roster in football.
Not necessarily the best.
The most fascinating.
The Dolphins traded quarterback Quinn Ewers to Jacksonville and acquired Kyle McCord from Green Bay, leaving Malik Willis and McCord as their primary quarterbacks following Sunday’s cuts. They also released linebacker Tyrel Dodson, who led Miami with 129 tackles last season.
Then Monday arrived.
Miami claimed an NFL-high seven players off waivers.
That’s not tweaking the bottom of a roster.
That’s continuing a reconstruction.
The Dolphins also entered the season carrying enormous dead-cap commitments, and their roster contains significant youth at several positions.
Maybe that is entirely intentional.
If this is a developmental year, then aggressive roster churn makes sense.
But Miami still has talented veterans such as De’Von Achane and Zach Sieler.
So what’s the goal?
Compete now?
Evaluate everyone?
Reset for 2027?
The answer will determine how we interpret everything Miami does this season.
2. New York Jets
The question: Who exactly is backing up Geno Smith?
The Jets did something sensible Sunday.
They traded for Raiders offensive lineman Jordan Meredith, addressing a depth problem on the interior.
But two obvious questions remain.
Quarterback.
Kicker.
Rookie Cade Klubnik currently sits behind Geno Smith, but New York’s situation has already generated speculation about adding a veteran such as Will Levis, Josh Johnson or Jake Browning.
That tells you something.
Klubnik may eventually be the future.
That doesn’t automatically make him the ideal emergency quarterback for a team trying to win games in 2026.
Then there’s Jason Sanders.
He survived cutdown despite an uneven preseason, leaving special teams as another area that doesn’t feel completely resolved.
New York’s roster is improved.
I’m just not convinced it’s finished.
3. Philadelphia Eagles
The question: Why four quarterbacks?
Philadelphia kept:
Jalen Hurts.
Andy Dalton.
Tanner McKee.
Cole Payton.
Four quarterbacks on a 53-man roster.
That’s unusual enough to demand explanation.
Philadelphia also cut multiple 2026 draft picks, including all three of its seventh-round selections, meaning the Eagles were willing to expose younger players while preserving four quarterback spots.
Maybe there’s another move coming.
Maybe Philadelphia believes Payton would’ve been claimed.
Maybe the Eagles value quarterback depth more than almost anyone else.
All reasonable explanations.
But roster spots are currency.
Every quarterback retained means one fewer defensive back, special-teams player or developmental lineman.
If everyone remains when Week 1 arrives, Philadelphia clearly believes that tradeoff is worthwhile.
I’m interested to see why.
4. New York Giants
The question: Is there enough depth at receiver and edge?
There are plenty of reasons to like what New York did.
Odell Beckham Jr. completed his comeback.
The Giants have Malik Nabers.
Jaxson Dart has veteran support.
The offensive line looks improved.
But look deeper.
New York kept only five wide receivers on the initial roster.
That becomes more concerning given Beckham’s age and the normal injury attrition at the position.
Then look at edge.
The Giants kept only three pure edge defenders, with Brian Burns leading the group.
Maybe versatility elsewhere makes that less concerning.
Maybe the practice squad solves it.
But those numbers are thin.
There is also real risk in entering the season with rookie specialists at both kicker and long snapper, even if both earned their jobs during camp.
John Harbaugh’s first Giants roster has plenty of upside.
It also doesn’t leave a lot of margin at several spots.
5. Dallas Cowboys
The question: Did Dallas create new problems while solving old ones?
The Cowboys made one of cutdown weekend’s most intriguing trades by acquiring offensive tackle Broderick Jones from Pittsburgh.
That’s aggressive.
I like aggressive.
But the rest of the roster created several questions.
Dallas surprisingly released second-year running back Jaydon Blue, then claimed Emari Demercado off waivers Monday.
The Cowboys also kept three quarterbacks.
Their defensive tackle room has essentially been rebuilt.
And their interior offensive-line depth looks thin after several cuts.
None of those decisions are automatically mistakes.
Collectively, however, they create uncertainty.
The Cowboys believe they improved their roster.
They may be right.
But there are a lot of moving parts here for a team with legitimate expectations.
Bigger Point
Every roster has holes.
Even Seattle.
Even New England.
Even the teams we’re already putting into January.
The difference is between a weakness and an unresolved question.
A weakness is something you understand.
You know your right guard isn’t elite.
Fine.
An unresolved question is different.
Who’s your backup quarterback?
Do you have enough receivers?
Why are you carrying four QBs?
Are you rebuilding or trying to contend?
Those questions often reveal the direction of an entire season.
And that’s why Miami tops my list.
The Dolphins haven’t simply reshuffled their roster.
They appear to be redefining what the roster is supposed to become.
That could be the beginning of something smart.
It could also produce a very difficult September.
We’ll find out quickly.
Because the “final 53” may be set.
The actual teams are still taking shape.
Want to write, edit, host, or produce with FPC? Join the staff →
Join the conversation
Bring your take to the huddle. Comments are reserved for Full Press Coverage members.
Strong takes rise. Keep it respectful.